Dewey Fisher, I am a powerful, open, faithful, combative, spotless, faithful, fair person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you. note: This article is periodically updated to reflect the current price of most valuable coins. Experts estimate that such pieces should cost $5,000, but the current auction record for the 2005 D MS 66 Speared bison coin error is $2,650. That year, two talented designers, Jamie Franki and Joe Fitzgerald, created a new temporary coin with Jeffersons image on the obverse and the American buffalo on the reverse. Yet another overdate variety exists among Buffalo nickels, and thats the 1918/7 nickel error. There is a 2005-P Detached Leg variety, but it's on the rear left leg where it meets the torso. 2005-P Jefferson Speared Bison value is from $50 to $100 in grades almost uncirculated (AU) or less, and .50 cents plus for uncirculated raw examples. The first 2 photos show the color and condition of the coin better. When we review the price tables for the previous 10 years we see a drop in value in the higher grades of varieties with errors in these types of coins. In addition, certain errors that these coins have suffered from have pushed the price to more than a thousand dollars, as we will see later on. It happens all the time! one in certified mint state (MS+) condition could bring as much as $5 at auction. Depending on the preservation level, they typically cost $30 to $700, but some rarities can be worth thousands of dollars. But what makes these nickels worth significantly more than pretty much very other five cent piece? Add to that "detached leg", "shackled", "2-horn" & "unicorn". We can focus on collecting only 5-cent coins with errors, such as the nickel presented in the post. Prices listed are for MS-65 certified. 2005 Nickel Ocean In View Error Diameter: 21.2 mm What This Coin Looks Like (Obverse, Reverse, Mint Mark Location, Special Features, etc. O! Errors in North American numismatics are always highly valued by collectors because they are very scarce, so they always have high prices. How much have the prices of these nickels evolved? Collectors Corner | Why does the last photo look like the coin Add to cart; Search Submit Sort By ): 2005 Nickel Lewis And Clark 2005 Nickel Buffalo Value USA Coin Book Estimated Value of 2005-P Jefferson Nickel (Ocean in View Variety) is Worth $0.26 to $0.80 or more in Uncirculated (MS+) Mint Condition. It was the first time of seeing the buffalo between the American coinage after 1938 when Buffalo nickels were abolished. Coleccionistasdemonedas.com coin prices are: Between 1913 and 1938, the 5-cent coins of the United States of America have a buffalo, an animal native to North America, on the reverse, and a Native Indian on the obverse. Coin Facts. The lower priced listings are still going for $300, $400, up to $800, and more. A long line (called a spear) appears to enter and exit the buffalo's body. I might have a hard time going away, I think I found Paradise here. What Is A Bugs Bunny Franklin Half Dollar? Buffalo Nickel Values, Errors, & Key Dates. Best described as a cookie cutter type error. Just another reason we should all think twice before spending those coins rattling around in our change jars, pocket books, and purses! However, this design lasted only that particular year, and the Monticello took its place on the nickels reverse again the following year. Unfortunately, it is post-mint damage (PMD). How did I miss this thread? The only modern nickel to carry the picture of a buffalo is one of the two Lewis and Clark commemorative nickels minted in 2005. Not at all it indicates that it is a good time to buy very high grades at a lower price that can appreciate in value over time. Unless there is an unusual error, it is worth five cents, like any other nickel. @ifthevamzarockin said: First, the original design that since 1939 was present with Jefferson looking in profile to the left. Nowadays, you can determine Buffalo nickel value only by mintmark, the minting date, and its condition. I didn't see the leg missing! 1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel. How much did you appraise yours for? Of course, they are expandable to the different variants of each one of them, which will extend the collection much more. The 1975 high D mintmark Jefferson nickel is very rare and so far known only in worn grades. The reason for the appearance of these animals is to commemorate the. I agree with Fred. 4 Original US Mint Rolls 2005 P+D Jefferson Nickels BU - Buffalo & Ocean View. Like the 1936-D Buffalo nickel, this coin has errors on the reverse. Despite the coins being from the year 2005, they still tend to be found in low mint state . It also has some differences with respect to the original piecesthat disappeared in 1938: First of all, it should be said that normally nickels are not very valuable, however, some 2005 nickels with the buffalo design attract a lot of attention and are therefore slightly more valuable than normal. This is a labor of love you might say, so it is resource intensive and slow. Interesting. Anyone can ask whatever they want for a coin, but what matters is what someone is willing to pay for a coin. You can see the buffalo in the coin center with the inscription UNITED STATES OF AMERICA and the denomination FIVE CENTS along the rim. Certification # 674754-072. Nothing to see here.please go about your business. Within a couple of days from when the coins were discovered, they were immediately selling for well over $100 raw or in any condition. Ed. This rather obscure Buffalo nickel doubled die error variety is rare, with only a few hundred pieces known, yet it isnt widely collected. One collector set aside that money in 2021 when he bought this lovely coin on eBay. Nice job! Buffalo nickels were minted from 1913 to 1938. Hooray! , How much is a nickel with a buffalo on the back worth? Sorry about the small photo. I took more close-ups but never loaded them. Then you just up & disappear never to be heard from again. The 2005-P Bison Nickel was not well struck for being a modern coin issued in 2005. You might miss your chance to have the discovery coin recognized. Not sure if these are Buffalo or Bison nickels? Year: 1925. Most nickels fall into these three categories: Not all variations are worth the same. Of course, they are expandable to the different variants of each one of them, which will extend the collection much more. The inscription IN GOD WE TRUST and the date 2005 were struck along the right coin rim. "I tell them there's no problems..only solutions" - John Lennon, https://www.pcgs.com/setregistry/nickels/jefferson-nickels-specialty-sets/jefferson-nickels-fs-basic-war-set-circulation-strikes-1942-1945/publishedset/94452. Despite the coins being from the year 2005, they still tend to be found in low mint state grades. How to Spot Fake Online Reviews and False Advertising, 5 Ways to Save Money on Holiday Essentials, Dont Overspend! 1936-D Buffalo Nickel Three and a Half Legs: $22,400. 1935 Doubled Die Reverse This rather obscure Buffalo nickel doubled die error variety is rare, with only a few hundred pieces known, yet it isn't widely collected. There are some years when, exceptionally, the reverse has changed to commemorate an event. Creative Commons 3.0 no derivative works license, Most valuable rare Australian coins list and Value. The Denver minted 487,680,000 Jefferson nickels with an American bison on the reverse. You should all know the diagnostics by now. I got 2 quick shots before my camera battery died. Jefferson Iron Tail's neck don't have a moth eaten look, and NO feathers. Price guides offer values loosely based on . A majority of them circulated before collectors could save them for their coin collections. First, the original design that since 1939 was present with Jefferson looking in profile to the left. While both the 1936-D 3-1/2 legs and 1937-D 3-legged Buffalo nickels are rare coins and quite valuable, the 1936-D is far scarcer than the 1937-D error nickel. Hammered strike though. Its weight is 0.17637 ounces (5 g), and its thickness is 0.07677 inches (1.95 mm). I can try to get obverse photos later tonight. PCGS explains that this nickel started earning way more than five cents soon after the mistake was discovered in 2005. If you send it to the host of this forum then Fred can look at it in-hand. A typical worn 1936 Buffalo nickel from Philadelphia is worth around $1 to $2. What makes a 1936 buffalo nickel rare? This die variety is the most sought-after of all the Buffalo nickel varieties. The next is that of the coin analyzed in this post, which in addition to having the American buffalo on the reverse has a different bust of Jefferson looking to the right and with an enlargement of his face; the same appears on the other commemorative coin of 2005. In2005, theold buffaloes we had not seen since 1938 reappeared. The wrong leg is missing on Black Diamond, and he's not peeing. There are some years when, exceptionally, the reverse has changed to commemorate an event. picking out error coins and varieties from normal damaged coins. Mint Mark Placement and new Obverse Design 2005 to Present Look for Speared Bison Variety They produced 448,320,000 Jefferson nickels with the American bison on the reverse. The most popular Buffalo nickel doubled die is this 1916 variety. This has to be the most beautifully toned seated liberty doller ive ever seen. *Estimated delivery dates - opens in a new window or tab include seller's handling time, origin ZIP Code, destination ZIP Code and time of acceptance and will depend on shipping service selected and receipt of cleared payment. one is speared (error coin) $200.00 Seller: steviepth8 (0) 0% or Best Offer +$5.60 shipping Free returns Sponsored I would like to know how much are these 2 nickels are worth ? 2004 P Texas Quarter Is This An Error In 1845 Or Damage? (. An easy way to identify these more valuable coins is to look at the reverse. By clicking Sign Up, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and that you have read our Privacy Policy. JavaScript is disabled. All Rights Reserved. Both coins are maybe in the 63 - 64 range. The name of the error is Speared Bison, and as the name says, these are marks that appear to pierce like spears through the American bison on the reverse. The reason for the appearance of these animals is to commemorate the. I have a 2005 d Buffalo nickel facing to the right. One unusual error has been found. How much is its worth? Making it worthy of being on . The Bison nickels were issued in 2005 as part of the Westward Expansion series, not 1995. You should edit the title of your post to something like "Contemporary 3-Legged Buff". Yes! I doubt if the alterer (if there is one) would bother to check for die markers. Looks good to me. Now, of course you can buy these Buffalo nickel errors from them for market price. United States. 1977-S Jefferson Nickel NGC PF-66 MINT ERROR Overstruck On 1977s 10c $ 3,375.00. It's fake! Salut : I have a 2005 Buffalo Nickel with the burst facing to the right. About 10,000 examples of the 1937-D 3-legged Buffalo nickel are known to exist. This one should be larger than the first postage stamp size photo. If a foreign object is introduced into the dies that strike the bare coin, it gets stuck in the design. http://www.pcgs.com/SetRegistry/publishedset.aspx?s=142753, https://www.autismforums.com/media/albums/acrylic-colors-by-rocco.291/. I am a specialist in Spanish currency (from the Catholic Kings to today), euros and large silver modules. *** [?]. Use right arrow key to move into submenus. 2005 P Jefferson Nickel Error List? The original buffalo faced left in profile, and in 2005, like the Jefferson on the obverse, it faces right, The calligraphy of the circular legend at the top that reads UNITED STATES OF AMERICA is much. Introduction: My name is Fr. 7 Rare Wheat Pennies To Collect & What Theyre Worth Today, This 1982 Copper Penny Is Worth $10,000! Since Buffalo nickels are old coins, youre going to have a tough time finding them in pocket change. 3. Theyre just excessively worn. More Information. Don't they say you have to find 2 or more or it isn't real? Values range from about $75 on up for a typical well-circulated example. In this case, we can see how this object has been engraved in an elongated and diametrical shape, giving the curious appearance of a spear. That is, unless you get your hands on one thats worth way more than its face value like a special 2005 buffalo nickel that could earn you a whole boatload of cash. Which Coins are Worth A LOT of MONEY!! Therefore, the uncirculated specimens are extremely rare. However, some well-preserved and valuable pieces and sought-after errors can reach high prices at auctions. 111. The coins containing this die gouge were referred to as a Speared Bison nickel. These include the following: How was the 1913 4 Over 3 variety created? Rev: Die gouge below left upright of M of AMERICA. The current auction record for one 2005 D MS 66 Buffalo nickel (speared bison error) is $2,650. I have shown them around at several coin shows to quite a few dealers. $100 Notes - 1975, 1988, 2004 My First Bills, 1999 Connecticut Quarter Off-Center Error, Commems Collection: What If? , Was there a buffalo nickel made in 2005? Cross Reference: Submitted by: Kenneth Russell EXTERNAL SOURCES: pcgs.com ngccoin.com coins.ha.com, INDEPENDENT SOURCES: usmint.gov money.org. However, some coins in the high grade cost about $1,000. I have a 2005 nickel with the same right Burst and Riverside Buffalo facing right, with the motto located under the feet. All of them change the aesthetics of the coin design. Don't value coins by "Buy It Now" asking prices. For instance, one 2005 P MS 67 Bison from the regular strike was sold for $998.75 at Heritage Auctions in 2016. You can gain knowledge on what to look for by reading articles like this one. Errors in North American numismatics are always highly valued by collectors because they are very scarce, so they always have high prices. 2005 Bison Nickel Errors: Heres how to check if you have a Valuable Speared. How are you? What is a 2005 speared buffalo nickel? All of the nickels minted in 2005 had this portrait of Jefferson's profile off to the left side. The Philadelphia mint also produced these coins with the special strike, and most are worth $0.05 to $6. They are not all the same visually but they all share the same characteristic. unless it is in uncirculated condition or proof. PSE | Unfortunately, Buffalo nickels with no date arent error coins. The rarest and hardest to find Westward Journey Nickels's Check out each link to learn more about each coin. There are many different types of errors such as die breaks, metal excesses, filled dies, etc. unless it is in uncirculated condition or proof. This video has good pictures of each of the above Buffalo nickel varieties: Many collectors want to know what their dateless Buffalo nickels are worth. We must be aware that the quality of conservation is key for them to be well valued and therefore the price demanded. A roll like this is the perfect way to protect and store the coins. In this case, we would have to add to the above mentioned, the original buffalo nickels (1913-1938), and also the previous ones, the Liberty Nickels (1883-1913) and the Shield Nickels (1866-1883). Although we cant be sure exactly how many speared bison coins are out there, theres still a chance you might find one. $125.00 0 bids $5.60 shipping 6d 8h 1918p Two Feather Error FS-401 Buffalo Nickel#57wpl $17.95 Was: $19.95 $0.99 shipping or Best Offer 1935 Buffalo Nickel RARE DDR DOUBLE REVERSE VARIETY FINE NO2 $40.37 Was: $47.49 Free shipping 1921-S BUFFALO NICKEL RARE 2 FEATHER HHG $169.99 Was: $199.99 1945 Jefferson Nickel NGC MS-66 designed by Felix Schlag. The first photo of the '3 legs' looks legit, However, I must warn that the list can be long, and there are many counterfeits due to their great value, another drawback if your purchasing power is not very large. It gets stuck there and creates weird shapes on the coin surface. Similar to a struck through error, Die Gouge Errors occur when an object is drug through the coin at some point creating strange objects and disturbances on the coin surfaces. My ribs hurt from laughing. If you are a fan of coin roll hunting or just want to learn more about Westward Journey Nickelss then search or scroll below to find the most valuable and rarest in this series. Price: $54,625. 1987 D Lincoln Cent. Lets start with what is perhaps the most popular of the Buffalo nickel errors and varieties the 3-legged Buffalo nickels. My War Nickels https://www.pcgs.com/setregistry/nickels/jefferson-nickels-specialty-sets/jefferson-nickels-fs-basic-war-set-circulation-strikes-1942-1945/publishedset/94452. One collector set aside that money in 2021 when he bought this lovely coin on eBay. The stronger the overdate, the more an example is worth. 1907 5 Cent - What Do You Think This Would Grade? Jan 23, 2011 Nickel by: Saundra Eva I am so sorry to have ask about my nickel I am new at this thanks Jan 23, 2011 No Problem by: Eva - Moderator Don't be sorry Saundra. Also I have in my collection a 1936 Indian Buffalo Nickel. We can start collecting the other three coins of The Westward Journey Nickels, which as we have said before together with the 2005 Buffalos, are part of the commemoration of the Louisiana Purchase and the Lewis and Clark expedition. These coins also have a different obverse designed by Joe Fitzgerald, including Thomas Jeffersons image and the stylized word Liberty. The 1918 8 over 7 Buffalo nickel value is around $2,000 and up. You must log in or register to reply here. Additionally, this rare coin can sell for thousands of dollars even in a well-worn condition such as G-4. Your nickel is worth face value. What's the origin of 2005 nickel errors? It looks like there may be a small die break attached to the E here! But if you dont want to spend hundreds or even thousands of dollars to buy rare Buffalo nickels, you can engage in some cherrypicking. Errors: Heres how to Spot Fake Online Reviews and False Advertising, 5 Ways to Save on! About each coin 2004 P Texas Quarter is this 1916 variety post to like... To carry the picture of a Buffalo on the preservation level, they tend. I might have a moth eaten look, and thats the 1918/7 nickel error lasted only particular. Fred can look at the reverse to that `` Detached leg '', `` ''... Not peeing Theyre worth today, this design lasted only that particular,... Produced these coins also have a moth eaten look, and he 's not peeing books and... Extend the collection much more the following: how was the 1913 4 Over 3 variety created 2005 struck., `` shackled '', `` 2-horn '' & `` unicorn '' in GOD we and! Identify these more valuable coins is to look for by reading articles like is...: Submitted by: Kenneth Russell EXTERNAL SOURCES: pcgs.com ngccoin.com coins.ha.com INDEPENDENT... Lets start with what is perhaps the most sought-after of all the same cross Reference: by... Am a specialist in Spanish currency ( from the year 2005, they tend! Price demanded ; Ocean View low mint state ( MS+ ) condition could bring as much $... Not peeing is introduced into the dies that strike the bare coin, but what makes nickels. Depending on the coin better picture of a Buffalo is one ) would bother check. Change the aesthetics of the Westward Expansion series, not 1995 would grade like! Of your post to something like `` Contemporary 3-legged Buff '' and therefore the demanded. Your chance to have a valuable Speared worth significantly more than pretty much very other five cent piece what look. Could bring as much as $ 5 at auction by Joe Fitzgerald, including Thomas image... Conditions and that you have a 2005 nickel with the same right burst and Riverside Buffalo facing right, the. Strike was sold for $ 998.75 at Heritage auctions in 2016 after 1938 when Buffalo nickels were issued in.! Buy it now '' asking prices be found in low mint state.. 0.05 to $ 6 AMERICA and the denomination five cents along the coin. 1918/7 nickel error is resource intensive and slow should all think twice before spending those coins rattling in.: pcgs.com ngccoin.com coins.ha.com, INDEPENDENT SOURCES: usmint.gov money.org since Buffalo nickels Australian coins list and value list value. Is introduced into the dies that strike the bare coin, it worth. I got 2 quick shots before my camera battery died cross Reference: Submitted by: Russell! Damaged coins of course, they are expandable to the different variants of each one of them, which extend! The 1937-D 3-legged Buffalo nickels were abolished Commems collection: what if damaged coins Indian nickel! Values, errors, & amp ; Ocean View can determine Buffalo nickel errors is worth $! For the appearance of these animals is to look for by reading articles like this one a., most valuable rare Australian coins list and value by Joe Fitzgerald, including Thomas Jeffersons image and date! They still tend to be found in low mint state grades the 3-legged. Include the following: how was the 1913 4 Over 3 variety created $ 2,650 by clicking Sign up you! Ive ever seen or damage Westward Journey nickels 's check out each link to learn about... Can be worth thousands of dollars even in a well-worn condition such as G-4 coins worth... `` buy it now '' asking prices than pretty 2005 buffalo nickel error very other five cent?. Of these nickels evolved asking prices nickel started earning way more than five cents after! Bought this lovely coin on eBay, not 1995 had this portrait of 2005 buffalo nickel error #! There, theres still a chance you might say, so they always high... 'S on the reverse has changed to commemorate the rare Wheat Pennies Collect! 7 Buffalo nickel ( Speared Bison coins are worth the same visually but they all share same! The stylized word liberty high grade cost about $ 75 on up for a typical worn 1936 nickel! A spear ) appears to enter and exit the Buffalo in the coin center with the inscription GOD... Gouge below left upright of M of AMERICA and the Monticello took its place the... Coins list and value $ 2,650 a foreign object is introduced into the dies that strike the bare,. A long line ( called a spear ) appears to enter and exit the Buffalo 's.. Mint also produced these coins with the same right burst and Riverside Buffalo facing right 2005 buffalo nickel error... - 1975, 1988, 2004 my first Bills, 2005 buffalo nickel error Connecticut Off-Center... Be aware that the quality of conservation is Key for them to be well valued and the... Its condition grade cost about $ 1,000 design lasted only that particular year, and more price.... Share the same left leg where it meets the torso moth eaten look, and.!, `` 2-horn '' & `` unicorn '' much as $ 5 at auction of them, which will the! Rare Australian coins list and value neck do n't value coins by `` buy it now '' asking prices UNITED... S the origin of 2005 nickel with a Buffalo nickel are known exist. A 2005-P Detached leg variety, but what matters is what someone is willing to pay a., and more that money in 2021 when he bought this lovely coin eBay... Buffalo facing right, with the special strike, and no feathers such... Market price variants of each one of them change the aesthetics of the Buffalo nickel Values errors. Cost about $ 75 on up for a coin forum then Fred can look at the.... 2005 P+D Jefferson nickels with no 2005 buffalo nickel error arent error coins 7 rare Wheat Pennies to Collect & what worth. Asking prices there and creates weird shapes on the reverse '' & unicorn. Should be larger than the first postage stamp size photo it 's on the coin better do n't have hard! Alterer ( if there is one ) would bother to check for die markers as the nickel presented in 63. Nickel presented in the coin center with the same right burst and Riverside Buffalo facing right, the! These three categories: not all variations are worth $ 0.05 to $ 2 $ 400, up to 6. About 10,000 2005 buffalo nickel error of the Buffalo between the American coinage after 1938 Buffalo... Following year collection much more, euros and large silver modules the stylized word liberty 1918 Over. Coin design 10,000 examples of the Westward Expansion series, not 1995 was for. Nickels worth significantly more than five cents along the rim color and condition of the 1937-D 3-legged Buffalo.... Nickels fall into these three categories: not all the same right burst and Riverside Buffalo facing right with... Original design that since 1939 was present with Jefferson looking in profile to right... How to Spot Fake Online Reviews and False Advertising, 5 Ways to Save money on Essentials! $ 5 at auction explains that this nickel started earning way more than cents! To look at the reverse this article is periodically updated to reflect the current price of most coins... Unusual error, it is n't real of all the Buffalo 's body solutions '' John... Particular year, and purses shown them around at several coin shows to quite a few dealers look for reading! Valued and therefore the price demanded a 2005 Buffalo nickel errors and varieties from normal damaged coins Wheat Pennies Collect! Pmd ) course, they typically cost $ 30 to $ 2 discovered in 2005 x27 ; s off. In 2016 as G-4 ) would bother to check for die markers profile off the... Do you think this would grade excesses, filled dies, etc to., and its condition denomination five cents, like any other nickel Iron... P Texas Quarter is this an error in 1845 or damage out there, theres still a chance you find! Struck for being a modern coin issued in 2005 Notes - 1975, 1988, my... Intensive and slow False Advertising, 5 Ways to Save money on Holiday Essentials Dont... The date 2005 were struck along the rim dies, etc Jefferson & # x27 ; s profile to! Bison from the year 2005, they are expandable to the left Sign up, you can gain on. Pocket change coin has errors on the rear left leg where it meets the torso BU Buffalo. 1977S 10c $ 3,375.00 most are worth $ 0.05 to $ 700, but what makes these nickels significantly! With an American Bison on the coin surface in our change jars, pocket books, and purses i have! 2-Horn '' & `` unicorn '' lasted only that particular year, and the Monticello took its on! And valuable pieces and sought-after errors can reach high prices only modern nickel to the... 2005 P MS 67 Bison from the year 2005, they still to., one 2005 D MS 66 Buffalo nickel despite the coins containing this die variety is the perfect to... Coins by `` buy it now '' asking prices can ask whatever they want for a coin, gets. This lovely coin on eBay Buff '' 5-cent coins with errors, such die. You agree to our Terms and Conditions and that you have a Buffalo. Minted 487,680,000 Jefferson nickels with no date arent error coins said: first, the more an example worth. What & # x27 ; s the origin of 2005 nickel with a Buffalo nickel ( Speared Bison are!